here is a review for Bagels Your Way:
A Gem in Medford! I stopped by Bagels Your Way for a quick bite and was blown away by the experience. The service was super fast, and my order was hot and fresh, exactly what I was hoping for. It's the perfect spot when you need something quick and easy without sacrificing quality.
The owner, JR, and his crew are the real stars here. Their customer service is top-notch, and they made me feel incredibly welcome from the moment I walked in. I ordered a hero, and it was perfectly cooked – the bread was toasted just right, and it was loaded with delicious onions and all the fixings.
To top it all off, I even got a free cookie! It was a small gesture that made a big impression. With such great food and a friendly atmosphere, I will definitely be coming back. Highly recommended!
Ann Williams
-
December 26, 2024
If I could give them no stars I would, the people at the front (besides Chris and the lady behind register) are nasty people with terrible customer service. This hasn’t been the first time I’ve had bad experience with this place. For starters they never answer the phone, my food was incorrect they wanted to blame it on being busy but there were only about 5 customers inside at the time of placing my order and they can check the camera and see. Not only did they not want to take accountability for THEIR mistake they had the audacity to blame it on me saying I took the wrong order as if the lady didn’t hand me my food again watch it on the camera. And the manager Joey is a piece of work. Claims to be “understanding” of the situation but constantly said “most people wouldn’t make a big deal over a sandwich.” As if my time wasn’t wasted either or my gas. I grabbed the sandwich on my way to work. If they picked up the phone the many times I’ve called it would have saved me the trip from work to get my order fixed. Claimed wanted to “make it right” but spoke to me in a condescending tone, justified his untrained teams nasty remarks to me. I will no longer support this business if this is how they treat their customers who made it possible for them. Disgusting. And to top it all off those people still made my order incorrectly. Unbelievable.
junior Hernandez
-
July 02, 2025
I ordered a BLT, but the bacon was cold and hard, which made the sandwich pretty unappetizing. It would’ve been much better if the bacon was freshly cooked and crispy. On a positive note, their iced coffee was actually pretty good. Just wish the food matched the quality of the drinks.
CB
-
December 07, 2024
Went here to grab breakfast on a Saturday morning. Got two sausage, egg, and cheese sandwiches with salt, pepper, ketchup. We were very excited to try it, but were disappointed when we got home to find no salt, pepper, or ketchup in either sandwich and stale rolls. Giving them the benefit of the doubt that it was very busy in there. Besides that, the staff were very friendly! Would definitely try again.
melody pastor
-
August 14, 2025
There is an employee by the name of justin there. I am an everyday regular customer at this spot. There is a viral video of him calling an innocent lady the N word. I will no longer support a business who has a racist employee.
Our Address
2799 NY-112 # 8, Medford, NY 11763, USA
Claim Listing: Bagels Your Way Cafe
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
here is a review for Bagels Your Way: A Gem in Medford! I stopped by Bagels Your Way for a quick bite and was blown away by the experience. The service was super fast, and my order was hot and fresh, exactly what I was hoping for. It's the perfect spot when you need something quick and easy without sacrificing quality. The owner, JR, and his crew are the real stars here. Their customer service is top-notch, and they made me feel incredibly welcome from the moment I walked in. I ordered a hero, and it was perfectly cooked – the bread was toasted just right, and it was loaded with delicious onions and all the fixings. To top it all off, I even got a free cookie! It was a small gesture that made a big impression. With such great food and a friendly atmosphere, I will definitely be coming back. Highly recommended!
If I could give them no stars I would, the people at the front (besides Chris and the lady behind register) are nasty people with terrible customer service. This hasn’t been the first time I’ve had bad experience with this place. For starters they never answer the phone, my food was incorrect they wanted to blame it on being busy but there were only about 5 customers inside at the time of placing my order and they can check the camera and see. Not only did they not want to take accountability for THEIR mistake they had the audacity to blame it on me saying I took the wrong order as if the lady didn’t hand me my food again watch it on the camera. And the manager Joey is a piece of work. Claims to be “understanding” of the situation but constantly said “most people wouldn’t make a big deal over a sandwich.” As if my time wasn’t wasted either or my gas. I grabbed the sandwich on my way to work. If they picked up the phone the many times I’ve called it would have saved me the trip from work to get my order fixed. Claimed wanted to “make it right” but spoke to me in a condescending tone, justified his untrained teams nasty remarks to me. I will no longer support this business if this is how they treat their customers who made it possible for them. Disgusting. And to top it all off those people still made my order incorrectly. Unbelievable.
I ordered a BLT, but the bacon was cold and hard, which made the sandwich pretty unappetizing. It would’ve been much better if the bacon was freshly cooked and crispy. On a positive note, their iced coffee was actually pretty good. Just wish the food matched the quality of the drinks.
Went here to grab breakfast on a Saturday morning. Got two sausage, egg, and cheese sandwiches with salt, pepper, ketchup. We were very excited to try it, but were disappointed when we got home to find no salt, pepper, or ketchup in either sandwich and stale rolls. Giving them the benefit of the doubt that it was very busy in there. Besides that, the staff were very friendly! Would definitely try again.
There is an employee by the name of justin there. I am an everyday regular customer at this spot. There is a viral video of him calling an innocent lady the N word. I will no longer support a business who has a racist employee.